Skip to main content

Doctor Who

  • Thread starter Thread starter Clean Sanchez
  • Start date Start date
CLASSIC WHO MARATHON
Love reading your opinions as always nutmeg. Really glad you are enjoying this as much as I am.

MARCO POLO
I finished listening to the CD today. It's one of only three stories for which no moving footage exists, unless you count the final moments of Edge Of Destruction. It's also the first story where there is any room for untold adventures, as it doesn't end on a lead-in to the next story. There was a pretty good novel, The Sorcerer's Apprentice, set after it.
I was pleasantly surprised at how easy it was to visualise this story. The relationships between The Doctor, Susan, Ian and Barbara have stabilised into more of a family unit, with any conflict being typical of family disputes. The Doctor no longer seems to want to murder anyone, which is a relief. Hartnell shines in his scenes where he's trying to con Kublai Khan into giving him the TARDIS back (still usually referred to as "the ship", and as "TARDIS" by Khan). There are other nice touches of humour throughout, like an incredibly camp character who flounces around in a way you wouldn't expect on TV in the early sixties (though I guess it's not a million miles away from Carry On). Susan's friendship with Ping-Cho is well developed, with good performaces from both actresses. The cast is uniformly excellent, including the actors playing Marco and Tegana. The BBC excels at period drama, and it's easy to imagine this one in colour, with vibrant costumes and palaces (probably realised on a tiny budget).
Marco_Polo.jpg

Interestingly, this is one of the few stories for which paperwork exists (or is known to the public) on how much the actors were paid (per episode). William Hartnell £210, William Russell £147, Jacqueline Hill £99.15s, Carole Ann Ford £63, Mark Eden £68.5s, Derren Nesbitt £84, Zienia Merton £36.15s, Martin Miller £84, Claire Davenport £42, Tutte Lemkow £63, Peter Lawrence £42, Paul Carson £36.15s.
 
Last edited:
Ooo you guys are making me want to watch those classic who, but I don't have time. Since I re-watch the new stuff, and...
As it is my weekend is getting consumed with DW.
Saturday night yeah, DW repeats and early mornings.
 
My fellow early morning time travellers - remember it's 5.30 am tomorrow.

The only confirmation I have though is the Brits on forums - it's moved an hour due to shitty UK Dancing WTS, can't remember the title is different.

And according to tv programs I have checked it is listed for 5.30am.

Unfortunately the ABC website has been programmed by a kid on work experience or something.
They keep listing at the weirdest hour. This week it is 3.30am, last week it was 2.30am,is that for New Zealand or something?
It is crazy, are they playing games or what?

And does everyone know DW extra is on saturday nights straight after the repeat of last week?
Keeley is so yummy, so divinely plummy.

Watching 3 times each week is very nice. Tonight I noticed -
1st view I'm transported, on the doctor adventure/trip
2nd I pick more of the humour and fast quips, the nuances and details or the story
3rd tonight, the actors, phew Keeley & Capaldi burn, sensational playing off each other

And she is my fave kind of villian, sexy/bad. oh so posh and civil.
Psi is really hot, he has to be back, kids will adore him - action figure coming. He can be so, so useful in stories to come.
 
...nutmeg and Meglos... I'm so enjoying reading your updates about the Classic Dr Who... it's a credit to you both that you take the time to post your thoughts about them... I read them with great interest... keep up the great work... cheers.
 
...hey kxk... I actually saw that Dr Who extra... what an added extra bonus plan that was!... the ABC really are pampering us with Dr Who aren't they?... it is sooooo good!... cheers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kxk
Another really enjoyable episode! Loved the witty dialogue, especially the Doctor's hilarious take on all things human. "It says KEEP OUT" "No, it says NO HUMANS".
 
  • Like
Reactions: kxk
Everything seems different this season ... the tone, the pacing, the attitude. And I love it!!!!
Another super fun episode. I hope Capaldi's Doctor is rating well, because he sure deserves to.
And I don't want Clara to ever leave, I love her more every week.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kxk
It's like they've hit the reset button on doctor who. Everything seems fresh and new and I love the character dynamics. My only complaint is that it was a generic monster of the week.

Also about this afterlife/heaven mystery - I hope it's not going to be an over-hyped disappointment resolved in the final episode.
 
Ditto to both of your posts, @nutmeg & @zac, thankfully Moffatt seems to have totally changed tac.

Maybe it was getting rid of the dregs - like River Song and all that shit. I hated her by the time she left. She really didn't belong in Matt's doctor.

It is a bit like he has snapped out of some kind of horrible depression, all that torture of Amy & Rory pissed me off.
And he was forever going winding with no end
 
Goodness I miss heaps 1st time around, I think I'm losing brain cells.
I am in love. Capaldi is delicious. Clara is a sprite.
The Doctor makes me happy - there is nothing that can touch how magical this show is.

And of course a bit of heaven to freak us out, next week looks epic:)
 
...just a little vibe that I picked up while watching this episode today... a little food for thought my fellow Whovians... as soon as the schoolgirl came into the picture it struck me instantly of the similarities between... well... see for yourselves...


dr who comparison of 2 episodes.jpg



...so okay... this was my take on this weeks episode... this to me was the 'setting up' episode that needed to be... what I mean by that is we didn't have an almighty romp or an intense storyline this week ... this was more of a setting up of how Clara/Danny and The Doctor are going to be getting along in the future episodes of this season... The Doctor freely admitted that he liked Danny to Clara which is good... it's obvious that Danny is a good match with The Doctor verbally at least... that is good too...

...the 'monster' was like a talking Tonka Toy to me... hardly menacing at all for me... the monster was really just a token gesture thrown in for good measure as far as I was concerned... don't get me wrong... I loved this episode... it was a great 'verbal' one for me... it was all about the dialogue throughout that kept me entertained...

...as I said above... I couldn't understand as to why Moffat and crew included that schoolgirl in the story... but I now believe that she was introduced to us to be a future traveler with The Doctor and thereby completing the group in emulating the original line-up of the show... they now seem to be sort of carbon copies of the originals in many ways lol!... let's face it... two teachers on The Tardis again?... what are the chances of that happening again if not by design?... but as I say... just my thoughts...

...just out of curiosity... does anyone agree with my speculation?... I'd love to know your thoughts on it... cheers.
 
Hmmm, @stickyfingers, well done, I think you are on to something there - and it would account for the improvement by Moffatt.
He's going back, and learning to structure, and if this is the result - great.

Weeeeeeeee, the Doctor is rating well too.
Just made the top 10 in total numbers, that is fantastic for a Sunday night and all of the competition.


Read across - total syd melb! Bris Adel Perth
10DOCTOR WHO-EVNetwork ABC1569,000130,000180,000114,00071,00074,000
11BIG BROTHER -SUNNetwork 9558,000165,000189,00092,00063,00049,000

And another 101,000 of us continue to watch live at ungodly hours!
I love 101,000 Aussies, that is an awesome number of us. And the ABC must be pleased, yeah.
And I think I just worked out the ABC website weird times - they are listing the time for Perth, 3 hours diff.
 
I thought Clara's days were numbered though? Isn't she out by Christmas and replaced by the grown up version of the girl student from the not-too-distant future? Courtney Woods, the disruptive influence.

Or did I just make that up in my head?

I thought they were almost going to start the swap next episode because it looks like it's set in around the year 2050 or so, and I definitely saw some one in the previews who could be a grown up Courtney Woods.
 
I thought Clara's days were numbered though? Isn't she out by Christmas and replaced by the grown up version of the girl student from the not-too-distant future? Courtney Woods, the disruptive influence.

Or did I just make that up in my head?

I thought they were almost going to start the swap next episode because it looks like it's set in around the year 2050 or so, and I definitely saw some one in the previews who could be a grown up Courtney Woods.

What is happening with Clara is all rumours at the moment.
There was an article mentioned it, and the question put to Gemma she didn't say either way but did say it may turn out to be logical for her to leave soon, something along those lines.

Rumours only.
short discussion here
http://forums.digitalspy.co.uk/showthread.php?t=2013466
Makes all the relevant points - ie she has a new love interest, is that the exit but he must travel a bit too first?
And an escape clause, " if you ever feel afraid...blah blah, you will tell me"

I want to know is she still impossible?
 
...I think that it will be a crying shame for Clara not to see one more season but the way that this shows swaps flips and flies about then I guess nothing is impossible... including Clara... the Impossible Girl!... cheers.
 
It would piss me off, she needs at least another whole series for Clara the girl/the teacher/the whole person to emerge.
She has had to be something else, impossible, odd, dying with Matt.
And Capaldi needs the rhythm of an established companion for a bit.
We - don't need any more new for a bit.
And i think, Mr Pink is going to take at least another series to develop his character, I reckon we have her for a bit.
Mr Pink is still a bit lost and ghosty.
 
LOVE Katy Manning. I wonder if it's too early to hope Jo Grant might be in the Christmas episode. Probably just visiting the set. Janet Fielding (Tegan) did it too recently. But a proper reunion of old companions would be fantastic. As it is, I love the way new and old DW meet in the middle, and Capaldi is such a big fan so it must have been a thrill for him.
 
Back
Top