• Welcome to the discussion forums. To get posting, register an account. You can also register with your Facebook or Twitter login.

Survivor: Winners at War (Season 40)

Meglos

HAVE A NECTARINE, GONK
Don't forget that for those who can, the finale is on from 10am tomorrow.
If I comment afterwards I'll use spoiler tags until everyone can watch it at night.
 

reepbot

Hooray for Press Gang!
Tony won when Sandra got voted out imo because she was the only one that was wise to his ways and could do something about it. But Tony played an amazing game.
 

Meglos

HAVE A NECTARINE, GONK
I can't believe nobody ever noticed his spying. He deserved to win for getting away with the sheer ridiculousness of that.
And Boston Rob was right - Natalie - and everyone else except Sarah, deserved to lose for not even trying to get rid of Tony.
 

reepbot

Hooray for Press Gang!
I think because Tony is so likeable, like he got those six fire tokens pretty easily, it can be easy to see why they didn't get rid of him or cast a vote against him at all.
 

starry

Well-Known Member
The edit seemed to make it very obvious Natalie was coming back, having 3 advantages in the return challenge was funny. Too many twists with the tokens and Extinction wasn't really very interesting. The main event at the end was the Tony v Sarah fire challenge, if one of them got to the end they were likely to win, but we'd known that for a while I suppose.
 

Meglos

HAVE A NECTARINE, GONK
I think Sarah would have won if she made the top three instead of Tony, and possibly even if they both had. Parvati's vote didn't seem to be going to Tony either way.
 

troynuncdicit

Active Member
I can't believe nobody ever noticed his spying. He deserved to win for getting away with the sheer ridiculousness of that.
And Boston Rob was right - Natalie - and everyone else except Sarah, deserved to lose for not even trying to get rid of Tony.
I thought Rob was particularly egregious last night, especially with his bizarre derision of Natalie... keeping Immunity? It’s just really unimaginative to expect her to mimic Chris Underwood’s game play for play, not to mention that this show makes a continual point to mock Erik for giving up Immunity in Micronesia.
 

troynuncdicit

Active Member
I think it’s also worth noting that with all the talk about how dumb people were for letting Tony get to the end, there wasn’t even a chance to vote him out in the finale since he played his Idol at 6 and won Immunity at 5. The only option is for him to lose fire, and it’s a massive risk to put yourself in that situation.

And for all of Rob’s talk about how Natalie didn’t make the right decision to keep Immunity at 4 (which is such a stupid sentence to even type out), wasn’t his first lesson in the Island of the Idols premiere that you shouldn’t go into fire if you’re not confident you’ll win?

Point is, Rob’s just an ass.
 
Top