It's pretty deplorable, I would completely incensed if I were either Elise or Emily or their family members. I know Laura-Leigh was pretty devastated, but at least she - and whoever Emily was up against - will get another opportunity to get their name and face out there. I watched L-L vs Elise online and Elise was really good! That alone could've been her big break. There is sooo much filler crap that they could have cut out to show some respect to everyone who was talented enough to get to that point. There was that horrible Green Day Battle Round of Joel's that I guess was worthy of airtime because it was kind of amusing because both were so bad, but I would've preferred to see some actual talent or at least a fair representation of all contestants.
I think with these things they have winners picked out pretty early on. As you say, classic Channel 9 really.