Skip to main content

BBAU Rewatch

Jamie: I actually like Jamie a lot in comparison to other winners. At this point of the first six, he is probably my second favourite. Aside from having his pants sag down to his knees and his overuse of the word like, I think he is mostly likeable. However, that is not to say that he is perfect, amazing and a legendary BB housemate. Much like the other members of this cast I see David as having three major points in the series: Pre-JamKat, JamKat and post-JamKat. In the beginning, he appears as this douche bro who is probably arrogant and stupid. Jamie and Katie both taught me not to judge a book by its cover, Jamie was in fact very relaxed, humble, intelligent, unjudgmental and just a nice guy. He does have that moment where he calls Katie a barbie doll but I think that was more just a poor use of words. Jamie was never volatile, never aggressive and reconciled any issues he had. It was easy to like him so I understand why he had support. The week he and Katie are nominated is probably him at his worst, where he like her spits the dummy and spends the week sulky. He manages to recover very easily, however, which then goes onto his 6-week under-the-radar narrative.

His relationship with Katie is without a doubt my favourite showmance in terms of character development and narrative. Jess and Marty were cute but they weren’t as complex as a couple as Jamie and Katie were. In the last few weeks before Katie’s eviction, they are the epicentre of the daily shows and all narratives once Anna and Michael are gone. Weeks 6-8 have such a ginormous focus on them it is impossible to not like them to some degree. He was an extremely patient man and must have been very interested in Katie and serious about it to be able to handle her at her insecure moments. All the teenage girls would have been simping hard over him from it so again, I’m not totally shocked he had support. When Katie leaves it left him the opportunity to shine on his own and I don’t really think he did that much. He was fine on his own but he disappears from the story later on which is mainly focused on David.

With John, Ashley and Gaelan all gone in the space of 24 hours Jamie lost his boy crew which then halted all their antics. I think towards the end the audience forgot he was there which allowed him to scrape through into the finale, also by David self-inflicting damage upon himself through his own self-destruction. It’s weird that if vote to save was used alone, he goes instead of Katie in week 8 and he doesn’t make it to the finale and doesn’t beat Camilla. Jamie won thanks to the evict votes which ended up making the whole vote to save method completely wasteful as he wins anyway with just vote to evict. I can’t think of a scenario where he would have been evicted in the series, maybe if he was up against Camilla and David but Camilla may have the edge there. I don’t think Jamie is a bad winner, he just isn’t a great one. I do like that he challenges stereotypes and made my assumptions of him wrong. I liked him and Katie, so I’m just fine with him winning.

Wow that was a lot to write. If only I put this much effort into my university studies.
 
At least then they were given the opportunity to defend themselves and in doing so the show kept control of the situation. Nowadays they'd probably be chucked out but the details of why would be kept quiet and they'd never be seen on the show again, leaving it down to speculation to fill in the gaps and any interviews being spun by the press, often leaving the situation ultimately unresolved for all those concerned.
*cough* Justynn *cough*
 
I am looking forward to 2007 as I have always loved it, but am sad that this will be the last time I'll get to experience a good Big Brother house.
I am excited to once again follow your thoughts into the next season. I rewatched 2007 in its entirety during lockdown last year (or was it in 2020? Same same, honestly) and I found that, like most of the latter Ten seasons, it also held up pretty well in the 2020s. It’s one of my favourites that, sadly, also ended on a low note due to the finale debacle. I always felt like the producers really tried to redeem themselves that season after 2006. They unfortunately failed.

I have really enjoyed reading all your very thorough and detailed analysis of each season and of every housemate, though. Also a very admirable feat to have made the progress you have so far! Well done.
 
Last edited:
P.S. Your thoughts and comments about the 2006 season have inspired me to go back and re-visit a handful of these episodes, too. :)
 
I am excited to once again follow your thoughts into the next season. I rewatched 2007 in its entirety during lockdown last year (or was it in 2020? Same same, honestly) and I found that, like most of the latter Ten seasons, it also held up pretty well in the 2020s. It’s one of my favourites that, sadly, also ended on a low note due to the finale debacle. I always felt like the producers really tried to redeem themselves that season after 2006. They unfortunately failed.

I have really enjoyed reading all your very thorough and detailed analysis of each season and of every housemate, though. Also a very admirable feat to have made the progress you have so far! Well done.
For me BB07 really is the stand out series of the latter years on 10 - I remember it far more fondly than I remember BB05/06. I think it was cast much better on the whole - yes, on the surface it's the same cookie cutter casting as the couple of years before it but actually they had a few people packed with personality.
 
I am excited to once again follow your thoughts into the next season. I rewatched 2007 in its entirety during lockdown last year (or was it in 2020? Same same, honestly) and I found that, like most of the latter Ten seasons, it also held up pretty well in the 2020s. It’s one of my favourites that, sadly, also ended on a low note due to the finale debacle. I always felt like the producers really tried to redeem themselves that season after 2006. They unfortunately failed.

I have really enjoyed reading all your very thorough and detailed analysis of each season and of every housemate, though. Also a very admirable feat to have made the progress you have so far! Well done.
Glad to hear! It makes it a lot more fun writing my thoughts with people commenting. It makes me feel like I am sort of experiencing it live. I'd give anything to time travel and get to experience Big Brother like my mum did at my age now.
For me BB07 really is the stand out series of the latter years on 10 - I remember it far more fondly than I remember BB05/06. I think it was cast much better on the whole - yes, on the surface it's the same cookie cutter casting as the couple of years before it but actually they had a few people packed with personality.
I have always thought the same. I don't think it's ratings reflect it very well and it's just a shame it's sandwiched between the controversial 06 and the dismal 08. I agree on the cast, surface level they're all the token choice of housemates but like the 01 cast they all bounce off each other well and stick out as individuals. There was a mix of personalities in there that are interesting. I am very keen to watch.

I will quickly add that looking at the whirlpool forums and also comparing to BBUS, it probably at this time would have been right for an all-stars season. I'm not sure if it would have been better to do a full blown season or a short spin off, but I think it would have been fun to do so. Maybe it would have been better to do it for 2008 to allow the horrible radio duo to ease in like Masterchef did. More on that when I get there though.
 
Yes, the cast was a lot better and more diverse than 2005-2006 in terms of varying ages and personalities. Also very keen to hear your perspective on the “us versus them” mentality that divides the house fairly early in the season.

I found it interesting because, while entertaining from a viewer point-of-view, a lot of what is said and done definitely wouldn’t fly today, and be considered borderline bully behaviour.
 
I remember watching 2007 to pay homage to any memories I have of the ten era from when I was a small child. It very much was a solid series and too often has it been overlooked due to the mess of 2006. Sad to know this was Gretel’s last series too.
 
Very sad. Especially how she went out.

Some of which has a lot to do with the final moments of the 2007 finale.
Lord I remember that finale being agonisingly long. There was absolutely no need to show the graph at the beginning. Then I think she got hit by a rubber chicken or something. You could tell she was done.
 
Yes, the cast was a lot better and more diverse than 2005-2006 in terms of varying ages and personalities. Also very keen to hear your perspective on the “us versus them” mentality that divides the house fairly early in the season.

I found it interesting because, while entertaining from a viewer point-of-view, a lot of what is said and done definitely wouldn’t fly today, and be considered borderline bully behaviour.
I'm very interested to see how I feel about Emma. I remember really liking her but like 06 my memory is very hazy.

From memory;
I thought Aleisha was cute, loved Travis for how nice he was, was in love with Billy and Bodie, loved Joel, found Zoran boring, hated Thomas and I think I liked the intruder Daniela. A lot of my memory is gone due to watching it when 2014 was airing so everything is muddled together.

It sucks that Gretel had such a short run as host compared to Julie Chen and Davina McCall. I would have liked her to go out better, I still am confused on whether or not the decision was hers to leave. Either way, BB was dead the moment she wasn't to be involved. I think 2007 had potential to move BB on to a better path but the turkey slap seemed to have done too much damage to it's reputation.
 
Lord I remember that finale being agonisingly long. There was absolutely no need to show the graph at the beginning. Then I think she got hit by a rubber chicken or something. You could tell she was done.
I know we’re jumping ahead by talking about this (sorry @Zcsund1234) but, and perhaps it’s my background in live production brain talking, but I still stand by my belief that they really went above and beyond to meticulously plan a great finale event that year (okay maybe minus the pantomime). You could just tell, particularly with the attempt at re-introducing elements of the 2001-2003 finales, that they at least tried… and then it all just went to shit because of one silly mistake at the start of the night.

The leaked daytime rehearsal footage of the finale that’s out there at least gives us some semblance of what could have been.

I also somewhat believe that the impact of what occurred that night contributed largely to the demise of genuine live television in Australia. It was cringe to watch even 13 years later, I can only imagine the chaos that was happening behind-the-scenes and within the network at the time…
 
and then it all just went to shit because of one silly mistake at the start of the night.
I actually can't remember what this is about, but don't tell me, let's see if it comes back to me when I reach the finale. I remember reading a lot of articles years ago about the finale and Gretel.

A bit to go before then though lol, Day 2 and I haven't even watched Billy go in yet. I actually like the Mr X twist. It's a bit of a spin on The X factor twist from BBUS4 and I think it had potential on paper to be funny having a girl with her ex and current bf in the house at the same time. Unfortunately for the producers the two men ended up getting along quite well. But I think if you put the right people in for the twist it could result in some great television.

Here is a funny moment I've always liked from Gretel. During the Day 2 Game On Live special when Zoran and Susannah are voted in and the audience had already been shown the graph, at 46:38 and 49:50 she is just like "we already know whats gonna happen". It's just a funny off-script moment that has always made me appreciate her. I love how she always goes off script and even mocks the forced professionalism that a TV host is supposed to display. Sonia would just read the script and do as told, Gretel was always able to make a boring moment funny.

 
So impressed with your progress zscund, and I am really enjoying your analysis. Who would have thought such analysis and discussion would be going on in 2022? I also really like 2007 but I often feel like I’m not meant to, like it was so far from the original series or something. But it was well paced with good HMs and enough “twists” to captivate viewers without going the way of 08 with nothing but twists.
 
So impressed with your progress zscund, and I am really enjoying your analysis. Who would have thought such analysis and discussion would be going on in 2022? I also really like 2007 but I often feel like I’m not meant to, like it was so far from the original series or something. But it was well paced with good HMs and enough “twists” to captivate viewers without going the way of 08 with nothing but twists.
I think my progress is also telling of my lack of life right now :laugh: but I am really enjoy going back and rewatching these and writing about them. Old US seasons are discussed daily on reddit, I wish there was more of that with AU seasons but the unfortunate thing is that it is only available on youtube and with the show having extensive breaks the modern audience is very separated from the older seasons.

I really liked 2007. Before I watched these with my mum all those years ago I read about a few of them and 2007 was the one that interested me the most. I think it was because I was very attracted to Billy and wanted to watch him lol. I remember when I dyed my hair blonde and watched this season with a friend and he told me I looked like Billy and I was super happy.
 
The difference has been that BBUS has been running for 23 consecutive series and has managed to onboard new fans. BBAU on the other hand seems to ride the nostalgia wave with groups of fans returning each time the show is revived. Newer recruits seem to be rare.
 
Last edited:
The difference has been that BBUS has been running for 23 consecutive series and has managed to onboard new fans. BBAU on the other hand seems to ride the nostalgia wave with groups of fans returning each time the show is revived. Newer recruits seem to be rare.
It sucks that it has worked out that way for BBAU. Also with BBUS theres less to watch with only 30 45 minute episodes per season, so it is a lot less intimidating to binge for a new fan in comparison.
 
Back
Top