Big Brother All Stars........A Good Idea For 2015 or 2016?

[Evan44]

I reckon it is long overdue.

 

[the Theorist]

No.

 

[Rison]

I reckon it is long overdue.

No.

It's such a bad idea, Nine have just asked someone to get them their green light.

 

[BuuYaa]

LOL After this season? They need to redeem first. All-Stars is not something you go with after a crappy season

 

[LifeBeyondTheLens]

I think it would be boring. Well for me at least, I like seeing new people and getting to know the new people and how they behave etc. Seeing the old housemates will be so boring for me.

 

[marquisite]

I've said it before, and I'll say it again (since the All Stars idea was brought up again also). If it happens, then it should be a mini series (40 days tops, but 21-28 would be better) and be a 'second chance' format. That means no previous winners. I think that's the only way it'd work...

 

[destroy_robots]

An All-stars *may* work, but only if it includes winners/notable HM's from non-Aussie BB a well.

Global All Stars if you will. Our best HM's, put in a house with UK's best, USA's best, etc..

 

[Frankyfurt]

An All-stars *may* work, but only if it includes winners/notable HM's from non-Aussie BB a well.

Global All Stars if you will. Our best HM's, put in a house with UK's best, USA's best, etc..

No way.

 

[Elkii]

The "all stars" concept doesn't really work for Big Brother. It'd be too dull.

 

[Fiona]

The "all stars" concept doesn't really work for Big Brother. It'd be too dull.

A bit like Celebrity and that word can be used very tenuously, BB?

 

[Shackles]

LOL After this season? They need to redeem first. All-Stars is not something you go with after a crappy season

Really? I think, after a bad season all-stars would stand out and be a breath a fresh air.

 

[Patty4real]

another season of fuken tulli the pretend lesbien no tankyou xoxoxoox

 

[inumeenu]

This would be the worst idea.

 

[hawaiianshirt]

I always thought the all stars series' ruined the idea of BB being a 'once in a lifetime' experience

 

[Fiona]

I've said it before, and I'll say it again (since the All Stars idea was brought up again also). If it happens, then it should be a mini series (40 days tops, but 21-28 would be better) and be a 'second chance' format. That means no previous winners. I think that's the only way it'd work...

Keep it fast paced and keep us wanting more instead of getting bogged down in the crappy aspects of it. I could handle that as a viewer.

 

[pecan]

I would love it to happen, but not on Channel 9. Not after the way they've treated the format this year. It would also depend on who you could get to come back, who would be prepared to leave the children they've had since leaving the show. Regina, Chrissie, Fitzy and Aleisha for instance, all have children now (does Ashalea, does anyone know?). Nathan and Fitzy have successful radio careers.

I would agree it should be a shorter series if it were to happen.

 

[Lucas]

Oh god no! It would be sooooooo boring.

 

[Brekkie]

Just don't think it would work with BB Australia. A mixed series might have been better - had they done the pairs twist by buddying up a newbie with an oldie that could have worked, plus it also stops it being oldies vs newbies too.

 

[iJake]

I don't think it'd work, especially not in the way Channel 9 produces the show. Although I guess it would be slightly interesting to see how some Channel 10 favourites come across in an extremely edited, family friendly Big Brother, but that wouldn't be very good for Nine, I don't think, because it would just highlight how much their version pales in comparison.

 

[Kismet]

I reckon it is long overdue.

NO, as no doubt Bree and "The Logans" would be part of it and I don't want to smash my TV screen