-
Welcome to the discussion forums. To get posting, register an account.
-
FYI: The site will be unavailable for much of Sunday 21 December and possibly Monday while we do some maintenance 🔧
Ed vs. Drew: Who's hotter?
- Thread starter pinecone
- Start date
It did seem very close, could see crust on his nose ring which was kinda gross
kxk
SAPIOSEXUAL
Yep camera dude couldn't believe those eyes either, and they give us a good all around look also, 1st noms he got different angles from anyone else
They did the same with Ed last week, and I think Tahan.
To be honest, I actually think it's a really subtle (but clever) camera tactic. It's usually the "hot" HM's they do it to so I'm guessing it's just their way of "persuading" the teenage viewers without them even realising it.
mikidiki
Well-Known Member
Ben - 1/10
Caleb - 5.5/10 (just passable)
Matt - 6.5/10
Drew - DUH!!!!
Ed - 9.5/10
Tim - This is a real hard one! For some reason I look at him more just like a younger brother that likes to joke around and it sort of feels wrong having to "rate" his looks. Strange, I just don't have it in me to rate him (not that I think he's ugly because he isn't - he would be better looking if he cut his hair and had a shave)
Rohan - 2.5/10
Xavier - 4/10 - His personality makes me find him quite ugly now (another hard one to rate)
Have I missed anyone?
Last edited:
Shackles
The pen is mightier than the sword.
How I would rate the men (based on sexual attraction):
Ben- 1/10: He's more awkward looking than 'ugly' (his actions make him cute but in a baby way). Anyway, as a gay guy I find it sad that BB constantly picks on goofy looking, excessively feminine gays when there are so many Ed/Drew-ish type of gay men out there.
Caleb - 2/10: Only because his body and personality raises it a bit. Excuse the harsh rating, he is just far from my type.
Matt - 7/10: In the beginning I found him more attractive than Ed, but I don't know I sort of lost the attraction towards him as the show progressed. He is still cute and he reminds me of Joseph Gordon Levitt (who is sexy).
Drew - 4/10: Again, I'm basing this scale on sexual attraction. He's good looking, but I'm not attracted to him and would never be (to a guy that looks like him). He is just too 'pretty' and feminine looking for me. I'm not attracted to these Dean Geyer/Zac Efron/Jared Leto types who have piercing blue eyes, long hair and such.
Ed - 7/10: While he is more my type, he isn't as "perfect" as they're making him out to be. There is something about his eyes that I can't put a finger on. In short, he isn't that good looking facially. If he had Ben or Xavier's average body and their nerd-ism (with glasses too) no one would look at him or fall for him. Maybe not at first glance at least.
Tim - 4.5/10: He has brown eyes and I'm into those. Maybe if he were to cut his hair and act a bit more masculine, I could maybe be see him as attractive? *shrugs*
Rohan - 6.5: He is cute. I like Indian looking guys, they can be attractive.
Xavier - 3/10: Googly eyes, goofy looking fella. I like his hairstyle though.
Ben- 1/10: He's more awkward looking than 'ugly' (his actions make him cute but in a baby way). Anyway, as a gay guy I find it sad that BB constantly picks on goofy looking, excessively feminine gays when there are so many Ed/Drew-ish type of gay men out there.
Caleb - 2/10: Only because his body and personality raises it a bit. Excuse the harsh rating, he is just far from my type.
Matt - 7/10: In the beginning I found him more attractive than Ed, but I don't know I sort of lost the attraction towards him as the show progressed. He is still cute and he reminds me of Joseph Gordon Levitt (who is sexy).
Drew - 4/10: Again, I'm basing this scale on sexual attraction. He's good looking, but I'm not attracted to him and would never be (to a guy that looks like him). He is just too 'pretty' and feminine looking for me. I'm not attracted to these Dean Geyer/Zac Efron/Jared Leto types who have piercing blue eyes, long hair and such.
Ed - 7/10: While he is more my type, he isn't as "perfect" as they're making him out to be. There is something about his eyes that I can't put a finger on. In short, he isn't that good looking facially. If he had Ben or Xavier's average body and their nerd-ism (with glasses too) no one would look at him or fall for him. Maybe not at first glance at least.
Tim - 4.5/10: He has brown eyes and I'm into those. Maybe if he were to cut his hair and act a bit more masculine, I could maybe be see him as attractive? *shrugs*
Rohan - 6.5: He is cute. I like Indian looking guys, they can be attractive.
Xavier - 3/10: Googly eyes, goofy looking fella. I like his hairstyle though.
Last edited:
koo
Well-Known Member
Ed is your typical good looking one dimensional mannequin / ridge forrester / sale of the century male model with no personality (that we've seen anyway), whereas Drew is more attractive because from him we've seen intelligence, humour and kindness, which enhances his gorgeous face.
candysugars
New Member
Drew, definately. He definately has an X factor that Ed doesen't.
bluesugar
Member
I find it interesting how most guys think Ed is the best looking male but the majority of girls say Drew.
Caleb - 4 - Too bogan and blokey looking for me
Matt - 7 - Good body but his face is kinda meh
Xavier - 3.5 - Not attracted
Drew - 9 - Hot body and gorgeous face too. (10 when he washes his hair)
Ed - 6 - Muscly and toned but his I don't like his legs and his pecs are weird looking. Also his face isn't that great
Tim - 6.5 - Yes I ranked Tim higher than Ed. I dunno, probably cause he has a personality and he's funny which I like in a guy. But I still wouldn't consider him "hot"
Rohan - 2 - He isn't butt-ugly but still not attracted to him whatsoever
Caleb - 4 - Too bogan and blokey looking for me
Matt - 7 - Good body but his face is kinda meh
Xavier - 3.5 - Not attracted
Drew - 9 - Hot body and gorgeous face too. (10 when he washes his hair)
Ed - 6 - Muscly and toned but his I don't like his legs and his pecs are weird looking. Also his face isn't that great
Tim - 6.5 - Yes I ranked Tim higher than Ed. I dunno, probably cause he has a personality and he's funny which I like in a guy. But I still wouldn't consider him "hot"
Rohan - 2 - He isn't butt-ugly but still not attracted to him whatsoever
CrazyDutchWoman
Well-Known Member
Caleb. How old is he? He looks to be near his forties and I am not joking. Totally not my type. -2
Matt: Body is good but his face is creepy and his character is not one I like. 0
Tim: Not my type cause I do not like his eyes but I enjoy watching him. 6
Rohan: Like how he is, too short though-6
Ed- Very handsome were my first thoughts but too bland so the crush I had at first sight is gone ,. 7
Xavier: At first I thought he could be cute but I was wrong. 4
I voted for Drew because he is still exiting me, please nominate me every day Drew! while Ed (I keep on forgetting his name and that says it all) is so bland.
Matt: Body is good but his face is creepy and his character is not one I like. 0
Tim: Not my type cause I do not like his eyes but I enjoy watching him. 6
Rohan: Like how he is, too short though-6
Ed- Very handsome were my first thoughts but too bland so the crush I had at first sight is gone ,. 7
Xavier: At first I thought he could be cute but I was wrong. 4
I voted for Drew because he is still exiting me, please nominate me every day Drew! while Ed (I keep on forgetting his name and that says it all) is so bland.
Oh I agree with you 100%. I don't do greasy, or Mr Muscle. Physically and mentally, Xavier is closest to my usual type - average looking but nicely-groomed, with intelligence & personality
Xavier - 5/10...closest to being my type, but I'm not as attracted to him as I was in beginning - some unpleasant personality traits are becoming obvious.
Tim - 6/10...I find him more attractive now than I did to begin with. He has nice eyes and a decent smile.
He's full of spirit, mischief and charisma - I love the way his eyes twinkle when he's being mischievous. But he needs a haircut.
Drew - 4/10...I can see why others find him attractive. However his hair is greasy, and I'm 32 so perhaps in 10 years he'd be closer to my type lol.
Rohan - 3/10...not unattractive, but not my type at all.
Caleb 4/10 - much to 'blokey' for my liking, I'm not a fan of muscle-men - and I feel very neutral about his character. I think he thinks he's better looking than he is.
Matt 4/10 - ditto to above, but I don't like his personality much. Can see why others find him attractive.
Ed 3/10 - handsome but has zero personality. BORING.
Tim - 6/10...I find him more attractive now than I did to begin with. He has nice eyes and a decent smile.
He's full of spirit, mischief and charisma - I love the way his eyes twinkle when he's being mischievous. But he needs a haircut.
Drew - 4/10...I can see why others find him attractive. However his hair is greasy, and I'm 32 so perhaps in 10 years he'd be closer to my type lol.
Rohan - 3/10...not unattractive, but not my type at all.
Caleb 4/10 - much to 'blokey' for my liking, I'm not a fan of muscle-men - and I feel very neutral about his character. I think he thinks he's better looking than he is.
Matt 4/10 - ditto to above, but I don't like his personality much. Can see why others find him attractive.
Ed 3/10 - handsome but has zero personality. BORING.
lafirenze
Active Member
Ben - 0/10 - don't need to explain that one.
Caleb - 6/10 - I don't know why he's ranked so low by others. He's not the smartest, but he's adorable. He's got a great personality and has a nice bod. His face isn't bad either - if he relaxed with the tanning a bit he'd be decent.
Drew - 9/10 - only reason I don't give him 10/10 is because his style is SLIGHTLY too hipster, and his easiness bothers me a bit (not sexually, just how he's so emotionally attached early on). He's smart, beautiful (yes, beautiful), got a nice bod, nice hair, nice eyes, fun.. he's the kind of guy I'd hope for.
Ed - 8/10 - his face IS cute, don't know what people are on about! He's not as facially pretty as Drew, but he's a dude's dude with a slightly pretty boy twist. He's got a great bod, nice guy.. only thing is I doubt his sexuality a bit so I don't even know if I'd be his type.
Matt - 5/10 - possibly the best bod, but that's about it. I think I dislike him.
Rohan - 3/10 - his face is cute, but he's tiny and if he's really being himself, he's emotionally dead. I get the feeling he's acting though.
Xavier - 4/10 - meh
Tim - 7/10 - Am I crazy for ranking him so high? He's skinnier than most girls and doesn't have his life together, but I love his personality. I don't think it's a sexual attraction thing - maybe more of an attraction in general. He's cute too.
A
Autumn
Guest
Drew is hotter. I never understood the love for Ed. He seems like a nice guy, but he's always been invisible to me. Like a potted plant over in the corner or something. Not really a guy I'd ever notice was around. But I totally respect him and like him now since he is rejecting Jade and being a nice guy .. seems to have a good head on his shoulders .. and my opinion of Drew is a tiny tiny bit lower because he wont stand up for himself and put his foot down with Jade. He did call her out on some of her nonsense recently when they were in the circle thingy together. So that's something. But yeah Drew is way hotter. And much more personality.
Tesa Davies
Team Skye
Ben - 1/10 Bleh
Caleb - 4/10 Bleh
Drew - 6/10 Still too young and immature, I like a real man who likes women not little brats.
Ed - 10/10 He exceeds 10 in my eyes. Mr perfect for me.
Matt - 6/10 Bleh
Rohan - 3/10 Bleh
Xavier - 4/10 Bleh
Tim - 4/10 Bleh
Caleb - 4/10 Bleh
Drew - 6/10 Still too young and immature, I like a real man who likes women not little brats.
Ed - 10/10 He exceeds 10 in my eyes. Mr perfect for me.
Matt - 6/10 Bleh
Rohan - 3/10 Bleh
Xavier - 4/10 Bleh
Tim - 4/10 Bleh