Skip to main content

Ultimate Big Brother All-Stars Line-Up

hafeau

hafeau

;
I think it's safe to say that this years Big Brother has so-far been a bust - not only in ratings but also in story lines. With Tim Dormer going into the house it's safe to say that the Exec. Producers are struggling to find better personalities than they have found previously.
I think the majority of people, fans and ex-housemates alike, all want an all-stars where we see the best housemates go head to head against each other (for perhaps the final season on Channel 9 Big Brother).

I think we'd all like to have the best of the best in the series. In your line-up you must have a minimum of 12 housemates and a maximum of 16 - with at least three housemates per season in 2012, 2013, 2014 and at least three housemates across the 8 seasons on Ten.

My line-up:
  1. Michael (BB'12)
  2. Estelle (BB'12)
  3. Benjamin (BB'12)
  4. Tim (BB'13)
  5. Ben (BB'13)
  6. Tahan (BB'13)
  7. Priya (BB'14)
  8. Lawson (BB'14)
  9. Skye (BB'14)
  10. Fitzy (BB'04)
  11. Reggie (BB'03)
  12. Sara-Marie (BB'01)
 
  1. Tim (BB 13)
  2. Estelle (BB 12)
  3. Tilly (BB06)
  4. Michael (BB 06)
  5. Tim (BB 05)
  6. Paul (BB 04)
  7. Dean (BB 05)
  8. Bree (BB 04)
  9. Vesna (BB 05)
  10. Camilla (BB 06)
  11. Tully (BB 13)
  12. Bodie (BB 07)
  13. Andrew (BB 07)
  14. Christie (BB 05)
  15. Brigitte (BB 08)
  16. Nobbi (BB 08)
I couldn't do the 3 hms's thing. I'd only want Tim from last year and more from other seasons
 
hafeau said:
I think it's safe to say that this years Big Brother has so-far been a bust - not only in ratings but also in story lines. With Tim Dormer going into the house it's safe to say that the Exec. Producers are struggling to find better personalities than they have found previously.
I think the majority of people, fans and ex-housemates alike, all want an all-stars where we see the best housemates go head to head against each other (for perhaps the final season on Channel 9 Big Brother).

I think we'd all like to have the best of the best in the series. In your line-up you must have a minimum of 12 housemates and a maximum of 16 - with at least three housemates per season in 2012, 2013, 2014 and at least three housemates across the 8 seasons on Ten.

My line-up:
  1. Michael (BB'12)
  2. Estelle (BB'12)
  3. Benjamin (BB'12)
  4. Tim (BB'13)
  5. Ben (BB'13)
  6. Tahan (BB'13)
  7. Priya (BB'14)
  8. Lawson (BB'14)
  9. Skye (BB'14)
  10. Fitzy (BB'04)
  11. Reggie (BB'03)
  12. Sara-Marie (BB'01)
Click to expand...

I don't think the all-stars version would be very entertaining at all with the majority being filled with housemates from the Channel 9 era.

Personally I believe an all-stars version would never work. The housemates will all be too aware of what's going on.
 
Here's my original lineup:

Men:
1. Ben Williams (Winner, 1)
2. Peter Corbett (Winner, 2)
3. Brodie Young (2)
4. Trevor Butler (Winner, 4)
5. Greg & David Mathew (Winners, 5; using modified Sugar Sisters twist)
6. Nobbi Tanaka (8)
7. Josh Moore (9)
8. Tim Dormer (Winner, 10)


Women:
1. Sara-Marie Fedele (1)
2. Sahra Kearney (3rd place, 2)
3. Belinda Thorpe (Walked, 3)
4. Bree Amer (Runner-up, 4)
5. Vesna Tofevski (5)
6. Camilla Halliwell (6)
7. Layla Subritzky (9)
8. Tahan Lew-Fatt (10)



Intruders (Male):
1. Red Symons (Celebrity)
2. Daniel McInness (3)


Intruders (Female):
1. Rebecca Dent (7)
2. Alice Redwood (8)


----------------------


I posted this on Ben12's Facebook page, and I think he got a little annoyed that I didn't mention him.

Him:

"
No Allstars big brother for me?

You posted that on Facebook and didn't include me. Shame"


Me:
"
Well, that's because I thought you and Ben Zabel could work together on the side.

If it makes you feel any better, I didn't include Fitzy either"


Him:
"You included some of the most boring contestant BB had ever seen. LOL"


Me:
"
Oh...... well, that's the thing, I didn't watch seasons 1-3, 6, or 7.

I only got through some of 5 and two episodes of 4"


Him:
"
So the winners of BB 1 and 2 are so boring

They did absolutely nothing

They had to invent vote to save over vote to evict. Because the show was always having boring winners.

People who did nothing"


So, taking it into consideration, I made this list instead:


Men:
1. Brodie Young (2)
2. Trevor Butler (Winner, 4)
3. Greg & David Mathew (Winners, 5; using modified Sugar Sisters twist)
4. Nobbi Tanaka (8)
5. Josh Moore (9)
6. Tim Dormer (Winner, 10)
7. Benjamin Norris (Winner, 9)
8. Ben "From Brisbane" Zabel (10)

Women:
1. Sara-Marie Fedele (1)
2. Sahra Kearney (3rd place, 2)
3. Belinda Thorpe (Walked, 3)
4. Bree Amer (Runner-up, 4)
5. Vesna Tofevski (5)
6. Stacey Wren (9)
7. Layla Subritzky (9)
8. Tahan Lew-Fatt (10)



Intruders (Male):
1. Red Symons (Celebrity)
2. Daniel McInness (3)


Intruders (Female):
1. Rebecca Dent (7)
2. Alice Redwood (8)
 
I tried including someone from every season (with the exception of Reggie from 03 because she was going blind or something). I guess I was too hung up on the twins because my brothers are twins.
 
In no particular order, except Zach, who is my all-time fave:

(1) Zach
(2) Vesna
(3) Brigitte
(4) Camilla
(5) Chrissie Swan
(6) Drew
(7) Timmy
(8) Mikkaylah
(9) Katie (06)
(10) Joanne (o3)
(11) Paul (04)
(12) David (06)
(13) Jess (02)
(14) Merlin (04)
(15) Johnnie (o1)
(16) Tully

and as intruders, late in the piece, as I couldn't stand an entire season of factions on here:

(17) Ben2102
(18) Estelle
 
Okay with Tim going back into the house, it got me to thinking about a Big Brother All Stars series. If they were to do an All Stars, I'd love to see the prize money split. 90% to go to the HM's nominated charity and the HM who wins gets 10% for their time etc.

Put forward your ideal PAST HM's or HM's you would just like to see have another crack at it :) You can choose anyone, but I think it would be fun to have at least one from each year BB has been on.

My All Star Cast:

Season 1:
Peter Timbs

Season 2:
Mirabai Peart

Season 3:
Reggie Bird
Chrissie Swan

Season 4:
Paul Dyer

Season 5:
Dean Glucina
Tim Brunero

Season 6:
Camilla Severi (Halliwell)
Michael McCoy

Season 7:
Andrew Temment
Billy (Chris) Bentley

Season 8:
Rory Ammon

Season 9:
Estelle Landy
Josh Moore

Season 10:
Tim Dormer
Drew (Anthony) Drew

Intruders:
Rohan Mirchandaney (10)
Sam Wallace (9)
Bree Amer (4)
Vesna Tofevski (5)

I think this is an okay list, I could possibly change my mind, depending if people reply to this or not :)
 
Personal opinion:
If there is a winner's prize involved in an "All Stars season" I wouldn't want any previous BBAU winner involved. I'd rather see a "BB second chance" for some of the more popular housemates who did not win their year to have another shot at winning.

Because if they have already won their BB series they've had their turn, they know what it is like to win.
 
Men:
1. Fitzy
2. Tim Brunero
3. Tim Dormer
4. Paul
5. Josh Moore
6. Hotdogs
7. David the gay farmer lol
8. Ben Zabel

Women:
1. Sara-Marie Fedele
2. Camilla
3. Chrissie
4. Bree Amer
5. Vesna
6. Skye
7. Layla Subritzky
8. Tahan

Intruders:
Mikkayla
Estelle
 
I'd have so many more of the channel 10 housemates tbh. I also wouldn't want any previous winners or anyone famous (Chrissy, Fitzy, Bree, Blair etc)

2001 - Andy & Johnny
2002 - Nathan & Jessica
2003 - Joanne & Saxon
2004 - Aphrodite & Merlin
2005 - Vesna, Dean & Constance
2006 - Katie, Michael & Anna
2007 - Zach & Rebecca
2008 - Brigitte & Nobby
2012 - Josh, Stacey & Ryan
2013 - Tahan, Tully & Ben

Sorry didn't follow the rules :p I'd like a good mixture of faves, villains, hotties & people who should have got further.
 
hafeau said:
I think it's safe to say that this years Big Brother has so-far been a bust - not only in ratings but also in story lines. With Tim Dormer going into the house it's safe to say that the Exec. Producers are struggling to find better personalities than they have found previously.
I think the majority of people, fans and ex-housemates alike, all want an all-stars where we see the best housemates go head to head against each other (for perhaps the final season on Channel 9 Big Brother).

I think we'd all like to have the best of the best in the series. In your line-up you must have a minimum of 12 housemates and a maximum of 16 - with at least three housemates per season in 2012, 2013, 2014 and at least three housemates across the 8 seasons on Ten.

My line-up:
  1. Michael (BB'12)
  2. Estelle (BB'12)
  3. Benjamin (BB'12)
  4. Tim (BB'13)
  5. Ben (BB'13)
  6. Tahan (BB'13)
  7. Priya (BB'14)
  8. Lawson (BB'14)
  9. Skye (BB'14)
  10. Fitzy (BB'04)
  11. Reggie (BB'03)
  12. Sara-Marie (BB'01)
Click to expand...
This list, plus Chrissie & Dan from '03, Tim Brunero and Camilla.
 
I tried to create a cast as dysfunctional as possible (which meant I couldn't really adhere to the "3 from each series in the 9-era" rule due to the safe casting Nine have done)

Men:
Paul (2004)
Dean (2005)
Hotdogs (2005)
Michael (2006)
Bodie (2007)
Terrence (2008)
Ray (2012)
Justynn (2013)

Women:
Vesna (2005)
Rachael (2005)
Perry (2006)
Anna (2006)
TJ (2007)
Brigitte (2008)
Mikkayla (2012)
Tully (2012)
 
I won't follow the rule of 3 housemates from 2012, 2013 and 2014... Especially because this current season isn't over. I also wouldn't include anyone in the top 5 of their year.

The ones I've chosen are either the ones I wanted to win but didn't go far, or ones that I think had more to give:

01. Mikkalya (2013)
02. Ray (2012)
03. Brigitte (2008)
04. Nobbi (2008)
05. Emma (2007)
06. Dino (2006)
07. Anna (2006)
08. Dean (2005)
09. Ashalea (2004)
10. Saxon (2003)
11. Joanne (2003)
12. Damian (2002)
 
I haven't seen the seasons before 2006. So...(in order of appearance):

Camilla
Michael
Krystal
Perry
Michelle
Emma
Bianca
Estelle
Angie
Benjamin
Michael '13
Tim
Tully
Justynn
Ben '13
Tahan
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top